The recent box office success of Saiyaara, starring debutants Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, has once again opened an infectious wound that has been hindering Bollywood’s true growth for years: its almost pathological desire to stick to typical “rotten braindead tropes” like love stories filled with heartbreak and pain.
While a significant segment of the Indian audience openheartedly embraces this mediocrity, it’s precisely this collective willingness to devour cinematic junk that has led an entire industry down the path of creative stagnation. And then we, as viewers, have the audacity to ask for quality content from Bollywood. Come on, guys, we’re better than this!
How about we get brutally honest for a moment? Saiyaara, while reportedly a decent one-time watch, is far from breaking any new ground in Bollywood. Yes, many so-called “prominent” critics and viewers have rated the movie positively, but even many of them have called it “cliched.” But let’s be honest here for a moment, can we really trust critics these days?
Bollywood’s origins trace back to the early 1910s, and yet, after all these years, a large portion of the Indian audience is still stuck on love stories centred around this outdated and pathetic theme: bad boy meets good girl, sparks fly, then there’s heartbreak, sacrifice, and reunion.
In fact, this particular formula has become so incredibly insufferable that many people have now started calling it “chappri.” This isn’t innovation; it’s just the same tired romance tropes, gurgled and spat back out as a “new” story in theatres.
It’s Mohit Suri once again dipping into the same well that brought him Aashiqui 2, a formula that worked a decade ago but now feels profoundly stale.
And this is where the real problem lies: when a film that offers nothing new, one that actively embraces the most predictable beats of Indian romance, grosses over ₹55 crores by day three, it sends a clear, damning message to filmmakers: Why innovate when mediocrity sells?
These formulaic romance stories are nothing but uninventive, safe bets—virtually guaranteed to work at the box office with the backing of a recognized filmmaker and prominent production houses.
The so-called grand success of Saiyaara proves that Bollywood remains a prisoner of its past and is either unwilling or unable to break free from stories that are, frankly, insulting to the intelligence of a globalized, digitally-savvy audience.
Yes, the overhype (boosted by impressive PR work) has done wonders for Saiyaara. But don’t mistake it for any sort of revolution. No, not even close. It’s just another symptom of the creative stagnation that deepens every time a movie like Saiyaara hits theatres.
It may be a bitter pill to swallow for some, but we can’t deny the fact that a substantial portion of India’s audience has been conditioned for decades by the same recycled romantic melodramas.
Sure, it’s up to the people to decide what they want to watch. But from a broader perspective, it becomes clear that this endless recycling isn’t going away anytime soon, and may, in fact, threaten the survival of quality content in Bollywood.
While South Korean dramas, Spanish thrillers, anime exploring diverse genres, and Hollywood productions deliver bold, breathtaking stories, Bollywood largely remains confined to its traditional markets, often because its content feels dated and out of sync with global storytelling trends.
India holds a vast wealth of untold stories, diverse cultures, and complex social realities. Yet, these are often sidelined in favour of the same tired romance narratives. Just imagine the kinds of stories that could genuinely put Indian cinema on the global map, if only Bollywood dared to step outside its comfort zone.
Saiyaara’s success is a warning, not a triumph. It shows how a significant portion of the Indian audience, by embracing cringeworthy and conventional narratives, unintentionally fuels Bollywood’s stagnation.
The dream of seeing Bollywood acknowledged and respected on a global scale will remain just that—a dream—as long as it refuses to wake up from its self-imposed creative slumber. Stay tuned for more updates.
We’re hiring!
We are hiring two full-time junior to mid-level writers with the option to work remotely. You need to work a 5-hour shift and be available to write. Interested candidates should email their sample articles to [email protected]. Applications without a sample article will not be considered.
