Yup! That’s pretty much been the story for Prime Video’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 so far!
While most critics have found The Rings of Power Season 2 better than its debut season, the viewers and the entire LOTR fanbase cannot stand the sight of it. Yes, the second chapter from J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay’s creation certainly looks bigger, grander, darker, and more visually appealing than the first season. But at the same time, it fails to hide its hollowness, primarily stemming from its slow pace, overwrought dialogues, and an overstuffed storyline with too many subplots that seem to go nowhere.
Season 2’s basic premise revolves around Sauron and his cunning plot to corrupt Celebrimbor and create rings for dwarfs and humans. Through this plan, he aims to reign the entire Middle-earth by sowing the seeds of dissension among its residents so that they may never unite to take him down. Season 2 should have stuck closer to this basic premise instead of juggling with other unnecessary subplots.
The first season also suffered from this dilemma. However, we should give some leeway to Payne and McKay for Season 1 as they had the daunting task of cultivating a series that was different from the Peter Jackson films while staying true to J. R. R. Tolkien’s works. Season 1 undoubtedly required plenty of setup before taking things further i.e., to the creation of the Rings of Power. Halbrand’s reveal as Sauron definitely caught many viewers off guard as many of them started rooting for the character from the very first episode of Season 1. Despite its flaws, the first season had a positive hype with it. Well, that hype seems to be fading away with the latest season.
What makes Season 2 not as impactful as the first season? Well, there are plenty of reasons behind this scenario. There are way too many subplots and characters this time. One may feel a bit frenetic while jumping back and forth between different plotlines. Even the ardent LOTR fans sometimes find it hard to remember the intricate cultural and physical geography of Middle-earth. And we should certainly not expect the common viewers to know these details. To make things worse, Season 2’s complex narrative structure just fuels this fire.
After deceiving Elrond and Galadriel, Sauron tries to trick Celebrimbor with the help of his Annatar form to secretly craft more rings for humans and dwarfs. Then, we get to see The Stranger travelling with Nori to reach the lands of Rhun to know more about himself and his powers. Meanwhile, Elrond stops believing in the Rings of Power after discovering Halbrand’s real identity. He decides to seek the advice of Cirdan (the wisest and oldest of Elves) regarding the rings. Instead of destroying them, Cirdan optimistically wears them, and so do Galadriel and Gil-galad. Then, out of nowhere, we see the feud between King Durin III and his son, Prince Durin IV. The inclusion of Numenor and Isildur seems a bit overstretched. And we just lose interest in the show after watching Arondir and Theo, whose mother Bronwyn dies after the events of Season 1. Whoa! This is way too much to remember! WAIT! We almost forgot about Adar and his orc army and their intention to take down Sauron for good this time. See? This is what happens when there are too many plotlines in a show!
It is truly a tragedy to witness a story with so much potential and with such epic and beloved source material failing the way “The Rings of Power” has. Hollywood, in all its infinite wisdom, has once again demonstrated that even the most lavish productions can stumble spectacularly.
We’re hiring!
We are hiring two full-time junior to mid-level writers with the option to work remotely. You need to work a 5-hour shift and be available to write. Interested candidates should email their sample articles to [email protected]. Applications without a sample article will not be considered.
