What Is the Story About?
In the fifth and final season of You, Joe Goldberg returns to New York City, now living under his real identity alongside his wealthy partner, Kate. Though he has seemingly left behind his past as a stalker and murderer, cracks quickly begin to show.
Joe finds himself the target of blackmail from an anonymous source who knows about his violent past. The season turns into a psychological war as Joe tries to unmask his tormentor, who challenges him with riddles and moral dilemmas. Meanwhile, his public image as a reformed man begins to unravel.
As the story unfolds, we see Joe spiraling back into old patterns, proving he hasn’t truly changed. He starts manipulating and even killing again to protect his new life, all while being pushed to confront the truth about who he really is.
Ultimately, the season serves as a reckoning. Joe is no longer pretending to be the good guy. He fully embraces his monstrous self , not with shame, but with pride. The final twist sees him surviving once again, but this time, not as a man in hiding. Instead, he becomes a powerful, wealthy figure in society who no longer needs to conceal the darkness inside him.
Performances?
In You season 5, the actors truly bring the chaotic story to life, especially Penn Badgley as Joe Goldberg. His portrayal of the charming yet deeply troubled Joe feels as raw as ever. There’s a subtle intensity in Badgley’s performance, he makes us see the conflict within Joe, torn between his delusional self-image as a “Prince Charming” and the dark reality of his actions. Badgley continues to show us the complexity of Joe, making him simultaneously unsettling and oddly sympathetic.
Charlotte Ritchie as Kate Lockwood is a standout. She perfectly captures Kate’s internal struggle, living with a man she knows is dangerous, but also fiercely protecting her own sense of control. Ritchie brings depth to a character who could have easily been reduced to a mere bystander. Her quiet strength makes Kate a compelling match for Joe, as she plays her own psychological games, all while dealing with the weight of her decisions.
Amy Camp’s dual role as the Lockwood twins is a pleasant surprise. She brings both Reagan and Maddy to life in unique ways, Reagan’s cold manipulation and Maddy’s wild unpredictability are played with such conviction that they add a much-needed spark to the narrative.
Overall, it’s the human side of these characters, their flaws, their contradictions, that makes the performances in this season so engaging. Even as the show leans into its more outrageous moments, the cast makes it feel real.
Analysis
You Season 5 marks the end of an era, and for many fans, it’s a bittersweet farewell to the twisted tale of Joe Goldberg. Penn Badgley’s portrayal of the charming, yet deeply flawed serial killer has always been the backbone of the show, and while his performance remains strong, the final season ultimately feels like a convoluted effort to tie up loose ends, all while struggling to reconcile the show’s identity.
The season picks up with Joe living a new life in New York, now a public figure, married to billionaire Kate Lockwood (Charlotte Ritchie), and trying, unsuccessfully, to suppress his darker instincts. Joe’s transformation into a ‘Prince Charming’ is, at first, a fresh approach, pushing him out of his usual cycle of obsession, stalking, and murder.
Yet, by the time the show nears its conclusion, the plot feels more like a parody of its former self. There’s an inherent absurdity in watching Joe try to maintain this perfect façade while his darker urges, which the show has spent years exploring, inevitably resurface.
Despite this, You’s final season does try to offer some reflection. Joe is no longer just a predator, he’s a man contending with his past, trying to justify his actions as acts of love. This dynamic is interesting, but it often falls flat. The show has always danced around the idea of Joe being both a villain and an anti-hero, but Season 5 struggles to settle on where Joe stands.
It tries to make him a tragic character, but the repetitive nature of the narrative undercuts any genuine emotional payoff. It’s as though You doesn’t know whether it wants to condemn Joe or romanticize him. The show falls into an uncomfortable middle ground, unable to fully address its central question: Can we ever truly understand or forgive Joe for what he’s done?
Another flaw in Season 5 is its over-reliance on absurd plot twists. The season throws in a host of outrageous elements, mistaken identities, wild attempts at murder, and convoluted character arcs, that feel more like an attempt to tie everything together for the sake of nostalgia rather than delivering a coherent narrative. Sure, there’s the usual dark humor, but it’s often diluted by the sheer chaos of the plot, leaving viewers to wonder if the writers were trying too hard to keep things unpredictable. Some twists feel forced and come across as little more than fan service. For instance, cameos from previous seasons are sprinkled throughout the episodes, but they rarely feel like a meaningful addition to the story. Instead, they’re more of a nod to long-time fans, offering fleeting moments of recognition without any real emotional resonance.
The characters around Joe, particularly Kate (Ritchie), become integral to the narrative. Kate is a fascinating character, an imperfect match for Joe, caught between love and survival. Ritchie’s performance is perhaps one of the highlights of this season. Her portrayal of Kate’s inner conflict is striking, and she brings a quiet but palpable strength to the role.
The dynamic between Joe and Kate shifts from romantic tension to a battle of wills, and it’s clear that Kate is just as capable of manipulation as Joe. However, despite Ritchie’s strong performance, Kate’s character arc often feels underdeveloped. She’s too often reduced to the role of the long-suffering wife, left to pick up the pieces of Joe’s mess without a clear sense of her own journey.
The introduction of new characters, like the Lockwood twins (played by Amy Camp), adds a bit of flavor to the season, but even they are stuck in the show’s familiar, overblown narrative. Reagan, the cold and calculating twin, and Maddy, the chaotic wildcard, offer a contrast to Joe and Kate’s psychological games, but again, their roles often feel more like plot devices than fully realized characters. Camp does her best to bring depth to both roles, but the narrative doesn’t give her enough room to do much beyond playing to type.
One of the season’s more successful elements is its commentary on the toxic dynamics of fame and social media. The show explores how Joe, despite his violent past, manages to manipulate public perception through his new life as a well-to-do, seemingly reformed man. His ability to sway others with his “nice guy” façade feels eerily timely in a world where social media has made it easier than ever for people to craft and maintain misleading public personas.
This critique, however, is undercut by the fact that the show itself, in its over-the-top twists and sensationalism, doesn’t quite practice what it preaches. The hypocrisy of You’s own narrative is hard to ignore, while it critiques Joe’s manipulation, it does so in a way that feels self-serving, leaning into absurdity for the sake of entertainment rather than meaningful exploration.
In the end, You Season 5 does what it can to wrap up Joe’s story, but it feels like a show that’s run out of meaningful things to say. It tries to be both darkly comedic and socially critical, but ultimately, it’s the darker, more ludicrous aspects of the show that dominate. Joe’s cycle of violence, gaslighting, and self-justification reaches its logical, though underwhelming, conclusion, but the show fails to ever truly give Joe, or the audience, the closure they deserve. Instead,
it leaves us with a final image that feels more like a quick jab than a satisfying conclusion. For all its attempts at self-reflection, You never quite answers its own central question, whether we’re fascinated by Joe because we’re trying to understand him, or because we simply can’t look away from the chaos he creates.
In conclusion, You Season 5 is a strange, sometimes frustrating final chapter. While the performances, particularly Badgley and Ritchie, remain engaging, the show’s overreliance on its familiar formula and its struggle to make a statement about Joe’s character ultimately leaves it feeling both hollow and absurd. It’s a ride worth taking for those invested in the show’s earlier seasons, but it’s hard to shake the feeling that You overstayed its welcome, opting for spectacle over substance.
Music and Other Departments?
In You Season 5, the music adds to the atmosphere with a mix of eerie pop tracks, though at times it feels a bit overused, overshadowing the storyline. Penn Badgley continues to excel as Joe, balancing charm with menace, while Charlotte Richie’s Kate is a strong counterpart, mirroring Joe’s manipulative nature. Amy Camp’s dual portrayal of the Lockwood twins brings fresh energy to the season. Directionally, the series sticks to its familiar style with tight shots and dark lighting, but it occasionally feels repetitive, failing to elevate an otherwise predictable narrative.
Highlights?
Penn Badgley’s performance
The camera work has been strong
Drawbacks?
Poor writing.
The music has been lukewarm.
Too many subplots.
Did I Enjoy It?
At times, yes. But if you are a fan, it might bore you at times.
Will You Recommend It?
If you invested in previous seasons, definitely watch it. If not, you can easily pass.
You Season 5 Web Series Review by Binged Bureau
We’re hiring!
We are hiring two full-time junior to mid-level writers with the option to work remotely. You need to work a 5-hour shift and be available to write. Interested candidates should email their sample articles to [email protected]. Applications without a sample article will not be considered.
